How do I know when I need dental implants?

Doctor's Answers 2

That’s a good question. When a patient has dental trauma and the trauma isn’t that severe, that means the tooth can be saved, the first step is always to do root canal treatment to save the tooth. After root canal treatment you might need to do a porcelain crown to cover the tooth.

But the dentist would also say that the root canal treatment doesn’t last forever. Root canal treatment just buys the tooth extra time. It could be 5 years, it could be 10 years, it could be 15 years or even 20 years. Eventually one day the root canal treatment will fail, and when it fails, whenever that happens, then you would need to extract the tooth and do an implant at that time.

There could be many reasons why the root canal treatment fails. It could be that the tooth cracked, it could be that the root canal becomes reinfected, it could be that the gum disease around the root canal-treated tooth. There could be a few reasons why the root canal treatment eventually fails. That’s why your dentist has warned you that one day you would need to do an implant. The root canal treatment just prolongs the life of the tooth.

Another interesting question is that there are patients who say that “in that case, I don’t want to do a root canal, I just want to remove the tooth and do the implant straight away since I know that the root canal will fail one day eventually”.

I usually don’t advise that because there’s nothing better than your own tooth. Having your own tooth is always better than having an implant. So I normally always try to advise patients to lean towards having the root canal done first, prolonging the life of the tooth, and eventually years down the road when the root canal fails then we deal with the implant.

I do a lot of root canal treatment and to make a natural tooth look good, especially your front tooth, is quite easy. To make a front implant look good is extremely difficult. You’ll need multiple surgeries, not only to place the implants but also to graft the gums and all that.

If the patient is quite young, meaning in their 20s or 30s, our skeleton keeps growing so the rest of the teeth will keep moving down but the implant doesn’t move. So when you hit your 50s you’ll have this cosmetic problem that’s very difficult to fix. That’s why we always want to keep the natural tooth because this problem just doesn’t happen with natural teeth.

When your tooth cannot be saved anymore, and you’ve tried everything, then that’s the point where you accept that your natural tooth has done as much service that it can do for you and then you move on to implants.

Similar Questions

Can I have dental implants if I have gum disease?

Dental implants can also be affected by gum disease (peri-implant mucositis or peri-implantitis), similar to how natural teeth can develop gingivitis (reversible inflammation of the gums) or periodontitis (inflammation of the gums and loss of supporting bone). Should you have been successfully treated for periodontitis AND successfully maintained for a period of time (to demonstrate stability), then you can consider dental implants.

Photo of Dr Jaclyn Toh

Answered By

Dr Jaclyn Toh

Dentist

Why do different dentists disagree on whether I should have a root canal treatment or an extraction and dental implant?

Dentists choose treatment plans based on many different factors. Some of these factors have nothing to do with clinical data. As a patient, your dentist should go through the different treatment options with you so that you understand the treatment itself, and the long term maintenance required with that selection. Keeping the tooth by performing root canal treatment and a crown may mean that the tooth may still crack further and require extraction at a later date.

Photo of Dr Jaclyn Toh

Answered By

Dr Jaclyn Toh

Dentist

Ask any health question for free

I’m not so sure about a procedure...

Ask Icon Ask a Question

Join Human

Sign up now for a free Human account to get answers from specialists in Singapore.

Sign Up

Get The Pill

Be healthier with our Bite-sized health news straight in your inbox