How useful is a colonoscopy, and are colonoscopies really necessary?

Doctor's Answers 2

Photo of Dr Chong Choon Seng
Dr Chong Choon Seng

Colorectal Surgeon

Indeed, colonoscopy is commonly performed for 2 main purposes:

1. Diagnosis of a symptoms like PR bleeding (rectal bleeding) or Screening for colorectal cancer.

2. In the hospital setting, it serves another purpose for the treatment of patients with colorectal conditions like bleeding or even obstruction.

In terms of screening, there are standard guidelines to guide the necessity of it.

An example of this would be https://fascrs.org/healthcare-providers/education/clinical-practice-guidelines/colorectal-cancer-screening-and-surveillance-recom. This is based in United States.

Do check with any doctor/nurse or if you know anyone whom is a locally trained healthcare professional, there is no harm in having a casual conversation about this.

Photo of Dr Jason Lim
Dr Jason Lim

Colorectal Surgeon

Hi Cai Shum,

A colonoscopy is one of the investigative tools we have to examine the colon, rectum and in some cases the terminal ileum. The alternatives are a computed tomography scan of the colon (also known as a CT Colonography) and a barium enema.

The key benefit of performing a colonoscopy is the ability to directly visualize the colonic lumen through a high definition lens and biopsy the lesion if necessary.

This cannot be done with the other imaging options. The common example is the poorer ability of scans to differentiate small polyps from stool remnants, as well the inability of scans to remove these polyps (polypectomy) should they be present.

This leads to an additional procedure with the additional inconvenience, cost, and effort attached with it.

Similar Questions

Are there any alternatives to chemotherapy for breast cancer after a mastectomy?

Chemotherapy is an adjuvant treatment modalty aimed to reduce the overall risk of cancer recurrence. The benefit and need for chemotherapy can vary from patient to patient depending on the stage of cancer, cancer biology, patient baseline health status and relative age of the patient. Stage 3 breast cancers will generally benefit from chemotherapy and omitting it may lead to a high chance of recurrence. Depending on tumour biology and one of which is what we call the receptor status of the tumour ,will dictate if the patient is suitable for endocrine treatment (tablets).

Photo of Dr Radhika Lakshmanan

Answered By

Dr Radhika Lakshmanan

Breast Surgeon

Do I need a colonoscopy for tailbone and anal pain to rule out cancer?

Hi, The description of your symptoms appear to be proctalgia ani. While it literally translate to "pain in your anus", the persistence of your symptoms warrants a physical examination by a doctor. The causes can range anywhere from an anal fissure (tear in your anus), to deep anal infections, to referred pain from somewhere else e. g. coccydynia / pelvic floor strain (from your weight lifting), and stress.

Photo of Dr Jason Lim

Answered By

Dr Jason Lim

Colorectal Surgeon

Ask any health question for free

I’m not so sure about a procedure...

Ask Icon Ask a Question

Join Human

Sign up now for a free Human account to get answers from specialists in Singapore.

Sign Up

Get The Pill

Be healthier with our Bite-sized health news straight in your inbox