Which treatment, a root canal or a dental implant, is more time-flexible and will result in less bone loss after tooth extraction?

Doctor's Answers 1

Tooth extraction will always cause bone loss in the extraction site.

When a tooth is removed, functional forces cannot be transmitted to the bone supporting that tooth. Bone loss occurs to conserve resources (to build and maintain bone at the same volume). This is a physiological (natural) phenomenon that keeps our bodies functioning efficiently.

There are techniques to reduce (but not prevent) bone loss (bone grafting) at the time of extraction. Bone grafting using artificial bone does not produce the same volume of native (a continuation of the patient's own jawbone) bone. The biggest advantage to maintaining the natural tooth is that the tooth maintains the surrounding bone and gum. Only tooth movement (through orthodontics i.e. braces) can grow native bone.

Native bone is the best foundation for an implant. Grafted bone is more unpredictable (it can resorb more quickly than native bone) which may cause longer term problems with an implant.

Once an implant has been surgically placed, the same rules of bone physiology and healing apply. All bone injuries (fractures etc) require at least 3-6 months for healing before loading. Therefore, the implant can only receive a crown (the part that is used for chewing) after this healing period.

Natural teeth that have been root-canal treated can be crowned immediately (if the symptoms have cleared up completely). If there are symptoms that require monitoring, a temporary crown may be placed for protection.

Similar Questions

Are dental implants the best option to replace a missing tooth?

Thank you for your question. I am sorry to hear about your accident. “What dentistry procedures would you recommend to replace the tooth? Is implant the best option? ” I assume that the teeth in question are your 2 front teeth? The methods that you can consider to replace your front tooth would be: Dental Implant: Most stable and aesthetic if done well, highest longevity if well maintained. However it is costly and there is a need for surgery. (Dental implant costs are Medisave claimable for the surgical component) Bridge: Good aesthetics achievable.

Photo of Dr Joanne Lam

Answered By

Dr Joanne Lam

Dentist

Why do different dentists disagree on whether I should have a root canal treatment or an extraction and dental implant?

Dentists choose treatment plans based on many different factors. Some of these factors have nothing to do with clinical data. As a patient, your dentist should go through the different treatment options with you so that you understand the treatment itself, and the long term maintenance required with that selection. Keeping the tooth by performing root canal treatment and a crown may mean that the tooth may still crack further and require extraction at a later date.

Photo of Dr Jaclyn Toh

Answered By

Dr Jaclyn Toh

Dentist

Ask any health question for free

I’m not so sure about a procedure...

Ask Icon Ask a Question

Join Human

Sign up now for a free Human account to get answers from specialists in Singapore.

Sign Up

Get The Pill

Be healthier with our Bite-sized health news straight in your inbox